The National Intelligence Council has predicted that Islamic Terrorism will end by 2030. Around the same time we'll all be eating food pills, driving flying cars and living entirely in an imaginary world.
By 2034, the last murder will have taken place and by 2042, a scientific
cure will be found for crime. By 2051, even bad thoughts will have been
eliminated, and by 2062, work as we know it will be abolished and
everyone will mediate all day on the serious questions of life. "Why are
we here? What is our purpose in life? How can there be a National
Intelligence Council so devoid of intelligence?"
In the real world, by 2030, there will be thousands of emirates, many no
more than small terrorist groups, but some of which control sizable
territories. Some of these emirates will pledge allegiance to a single Caliphate like ISIS. Others will try to get big enough to turn into their own Caliphate.
There will be a hundred miniature Afghanistans fought by international peacekeeping forces composed of a
combination of local forces and NATO troops try to push out the bands of Salafi holy warriors, and their pirate camps, brothels
and drug labs. There will be drones over the skies of a hundred deserts
fighting Toyota pickup trucks with bands of hooded men firing machine
guns. There will be wire transfers from a dozen Islamic finance
institutions wending their way from the great oil economies of the
Persian Gulf and American soldiers, who have
never seen a conventional war fought in their lifetime, heading in on
another rescue mission into the territory of a Terror Emirate.
The United States of 2030 will fight some of these emirates, ignore others and try to claim that some of them are moderate. Clinton tried to work with the Taliban. Obama backed the Brotherhood. By 2030, the smart men and women who got us into this will conclude that the best way to fight some of these caliphates and emirates is to pay them protection money to fight the other caliphates and emirates. We're already doing that in Syria. Eventually we'll begin doing it everywhere.
In Benghazi, Hillary Clinton was paying protection money to an Al Qaeda ally for security. Today, Europe decided to pay protection money to the state sponsors of terror in Turkey. By 2030, we'll stop pretending that it's foreign aid and start calling it what it is. Or maybe we'll go on lying to ourselves.
Western countries are already paying their Jizya as foreign aid, trading
cash for the promise of stability. The United States and its allies
have paid out fortunes to Afghan and Iraqi militias during the past two
wars. And that doesn't even begin to take into account the sheer amount
of money spent on development in the Muslim world. It is likely that the
United States has spent more on Jizya, the traditional protection money
payment of the non-Muslim Dhimmi to the Islamic State, than every other nation had
throughout all of history. And that's just the down payment on the big
Back when the Marines first saw action against the Barbary pirates, most
nations found it easier to pay than fight. Jefferson's "Millions for defense, but not one cent for tribute" set us apart. The Marines came into being because America decided to invest in defense instead of protection money. But defense today is so tangled with tribute that it's hard to tell the two apart.
There are countless such private deals that have been made already and
there will be countless more made to allow Western countries, and their
companies and NGOs to function in territory controlled by Islamist
Emirates. And that territory will include international shipping lanes.
By 2030, most countries will have come to view Islamic
terrorism as a strategic asset, the way that Saudi Arabia does. They will recognize that the only way to transform
the strategic liability of Muslim terrorism into an asset is by funding
it and aiming it at their enemies. Islamist militias, will gain valuable experience, training and weapons by serving as the
barbarian armies of a decaying West that they will use to conquer the
West, the way that the Goth ancestors of Westerners did.
The America of 2030 will spend nearly as much trying to buy off the Muslim world as it will spend on trying to kill terrorists. We will continue financing the terrorism that we are trying to prevent while appeasing our killers. American soldiers will be stationed around the world in a hundred little undeclared wars, building generators for sullen villages before coming under fire from them.
The war will be endless. Both sides will hate it and will perpetuate it anyway.
Imagine the conflicts of the Cold War if instead of Moscow, there had been a thousand decentralized Communist dictatorships across the world with no central enemy to fight, and if the Viet Cong were coming out of
Oakland. Imagine the Drug War if the drug lords were aspiring feudalists fighting for a world government that would turn us into
their serfs. Imagine World War II if the Nazis were a religion that
anyone could convert to and immediately become a member of the master
race with the right to rob, rape and kill anyone from the inferior
But you don't have to wait for 2030 to see that world. It's already here.
By 2030, Europe will be a police state fighting terrorism by eliminating privacy, deploying soldiers in every city and criminalizing dissent. The EU police state will be
able to access the contents of any mobile device at a
click. Even speech that is still permitted today will lead to prison
sentences at worst or at best, mandatory reeducation at special centers
organized to combat extremism.
The bombs will still keep going off, but they will be a nuisance.
Europeans will learn to adapt to the occasional suicide bombing the way
that Israelis have. A bomb will go off, the survivors will be carted
the broken glass will be swept up and the television will praise the refusal to give in to
extremism and hatred, while prominently featuring the half-hearted
condemnation of a local cleric.
The No-Go Zones will grow and slowly turn into emirates. The authorities
will make deals with the local gangs, who will act as Islamist
militias. There will be lashes and honor killings in the formal setting
of Islamic law and no one will pay attention. Urban and suburban
enclaves will eventually become indistinguishable from Gaza. By 2030 the
first crude homemade rocket, made with plans offered on the internet,
may rise into the Parisian sky aimed at the Eiffel Tower.
But there will be immediate half-hearted condemnations.
Like Europe, the United States will operate a paranoid surveillance
state that its critics decry, even while both the state and its critics
support the migration that makes it mandatory. There will be
terrorist attacks, some thwarted, some not, including possibly one big
one, when an Islamic terror group finally gets its hands on chemical
or nuclear weapons from one of the Islamic states.
The America of 2030 will sink half its intellectual capital into praising
Islam while the other half will be spent trying to find more elegant
ways to kill Muslim terrorists. Homo Americanus
circa 2030 will be a veteran of two dozen wars in the Muslim world and of two thousand television programs, museum exhibits, books, movies and high school classes celebrating Islamic religion and culture.
Western leaders, like their ancient Roman counterparts, have
come to admire the virtues of the savage more than the virtues of their
own civilization. By 2030 it will be clearer than ever whether the
outcome of their bloody halfhearted campaigns to civilize the savages
with doses of democracy and civic institutions will have led to
civilized savages or the savaging of civilization.
Is this world of 2030 inevitable? No, it's not. We don't have to live this way. We choose to.
In 1969, John Lennon and Yoko Ono put up billboards with the message,
"War is Over! If you want it" to protest against the Vietnam War. Will terrorism end by 2030? It will if we want it to.
two sure ways to end a war; either by winning it or by losing it. The
world's most famous cokehead and mental patient duo meant the latter
when they offered their Viet Cong Christmas greeting, but winning wars
is still an option. It just isn't the option that we've chosen.
hearts and minds way of war will take us to the 2030 that I have
described. And that 2030 will take us to a 2060 and a 2090 where the war
is over because we lost.
If we want our civilization to end there, all we have to do is to keep on doing what we're doing.
We know how to win wars. We don't lack the tools or the skills. We lack the conviction. We aren't trying to win the hearts and minds of the enemy because we know we're right. It's a strategy born of a lack of confidence. We don't believe in ourselves. We need the enemy to affirm our morality.
The United States does not lose wars except when it loses the conviction and unity of its purpose. To win, we have to believe that we have a nation, a culture and a people worth protecting. The enemy believes that. It believes that enough to destroy us. If we believed it, the war would already be over.
Islamic terrorism is over if you want it. We have the power and the skill to end it at any time. What we lack is the faith that we are worth fighting for.